70% of Industrial Transformations Fail, Kotter Knows at Exactly Which Stage

John Kotter taught leadership at Harvard for 30 years. Leading Change (1996) remains the world reference framework for understanding why an industrial transformation derails, and at exactly which stage. By Mounir Telkass, founder of MT-Transition.

☎ Call: +33 6 59 15 73 54 Request a call back within 2 business hours

Leading Change by John Kotter, applied to industry — Real urgency, a guiding coalition, a repeated vision: the three stages that decide the fate of a transformation.

John Kotter taught leadership at Harvard Business School for 30 years. Leading Change, published in 1996, became the world reference framework for thinking through organizational transformation. Five million copies sold. But above all: an empirical finding no one has since managed to invalidate.

Kotter studied hundreds of transformation programs. The result lands hard: roughly 70% of transformations fail. And he identified exactly at which stage they derail. The book lays out an 8-step framework. Three of those steps are where the failures happen, precisely because they are the ones most executive committees shortcut or rush through.

1. Establish a Sense of Urgency: Real, Not Manufactured

“Without a sense of urgency, people simply will not give that extra effort that is often essential. They won’t make needed sacrifices.”

Kotter distinguishes between two kinds of urgency: false urgency (agitation, an explosion of meetings) and real urgency, where everyone understands, in their gut, that not moving now is riskier than moving. Urgency is built: through hard data shared without euphemisms, through blunt competitive comparisons.

This is the priority of the first week of a transition assignment, whether it is a digital transformation or a site turnaround. Before any action plan, the industrial director must make the real situation visible: degraded figures, sector comparison, lost client accounts.

2. Build a Guiding Coalition: Not a Lone Sponsor

“No one individual, even a monarch-like CEO, is ever able to develop the right vision, communicate it, eliminate all the obstacles, generate short-term wins, lead and manage dozens of change projects, and anchor new approaches in the culture.”

No industrial transformation can be carried by one person alone. It takes a guiding coalition that combines power, expertise, credibility and leadership: small, tight-knit, able to meet outside the formal structure. The most common mistake: the CEO believes that with his existing executive committee, he already has his transformation team. He does not: the executive committee is an operating-management team, the guiding coalition is a different team.

3. Communicate the Vision Ten Times More Than You Think Necessary

“In failed transformations, you can find plenty of plans, directives, and programs but no vision.”

In successful transformations, the vision is communicated by leaders at least ten times more than they themselves imagine is necessary, and through every channel. Leaders’ day-to-day behavior is the only vision communication that truly counts. A role usually carried by the transition HR director alongside the CEO.

A Transformation That Restarts

French subsidiary of an international industrial group, 380 employees. A transformation plan launched 15 months earlier, 20% executed. The board mandates a transition CEO for 9 months.

Real-urgency step, a two-hour Truth Committee: real financial figures over 5 years, lost clients, unfiltered testimony from shop-floor operators. The mood in the room shifts within the first 90 minutes.

Guiding coalition, a coalition of 7 people, distinct from the executive committee: 4 direct reports, 2 high-potential second-line managers, an external industrial consultant.

Communication tenfold: a daily 60-minute shop-floor walkthrough, team huddles, the same message repeated in different forms. After 9 months: 75% of the plan executed, gross margin up 3.5 points, employee-climate score rising from 38% to 62%.

Key Takeaways

Real urgency is built, not declared. No transformation is possible until teams have looked the hard numbers in the face.

The guiding coalition is not the executive committee. It is a different team, assembled for the transformation.

The vision must be communicated ten times more than you think. And what counts is not what is said in plenary sessions, but what leaders do every day.

An industrial transformation, unlike a digital or organizational one, is visible on the shop floor, and is felt immediately when urgency is false, the coalition is fictitious, or the vision is inconsistent with leadership behavior.
Mounir Telkass: MT-Transition, industrial transition management firm.

A similar situation at your company?

A first phone conversation, no commitment, to scope your needs.

☎ Call: +33 6 59 15 73 54 Request a call back within 2 business hours

Callback within 2 business hours.

The transition management firm 100% dedicated to industry. Operational leaders, mobilized fast.

← All articles